Spitfire Mk.VIII and IX
"No Cut" Corrected
Fuselages
for
Hasegawa 1/48 Scale Kits
Loon
Models
S
u m m a r y
|
Catalogue Number
and Description: |
LO48208 - "No Cut" Spitfire Mk.IX
Fuselage Correction
LO48209 - "No Cut" Spitfire Mk.VIII Fuselage Correction
|
Scale: |
1/72 |
Price: |
LO48208 - USD$21.75
LO48209 - USD$18.50
(Loon products may be
viewed at the Loon Models
website) |
Review Type: |
FirstLook |
Media and Contents: |
See review text |
Advantages: |
Ambitious project addressing a
high-profile error on Hasegawa's late Merlin Spitfires; high quality
casting; simple solution to short Hasegawa fuselage (no cutting); Mk.IX
set includes early stabs, small carb intake and wide "C" cannon covers. |
Disadvantages: |
Some thin flash requiring cleanup;
slightly wider engraved lines on rear fuselage. |
Recommendation: |
Highly Recommended |
Reviewed by Brett Green
HyperScale is proudly supported by Squadron.com
Some model issues take on epic proportions.
One high-profile issue of recent years is the famous "short fuselage" in
Hasegawa's 1/48 scale Spitfire Mk. VIII/IX family of kits. It is generally
accepted that the rear fuselage of these kits is too short with some further
compound problems due to this dimensional error. These additional problems
include misplaced panel lines. but more importantly, the taper of the lower
fuselage line from the cockpit to the rudder is too pronounced. The spinner is
also far too long, presumably to help compensate for the short overall fuselage
length.
Bruce Archer conducted a
detailed
comparison between Spitfire Mk.IX kits in 1/48 scale shortly after
Hasegawa's initial Spitfire IX release in 2001. His conclusion was that there
was no easy fix to the Hasegawa fuselage dimensional problems.
And so, the modelling community noisily divided into two camps. Some
modellers accepted that the Hasegawa Spitfire IX still looked okay, was nicely
detailed and was easy to build; while others thought that the error was
noticeable and rendered the kit unacceptable. Many modellers acknowledged the
problem but built the kit anyway.
There was never any "right" or "wrong" to these different positions, but Loon
Models now offers another option.
Loon Models has released two complete fuselage replacements in resin for
building a more accurate Spitfire Mk.IX or the later Mk.VIII based on the
Hasegawa kits.
LO48208 - Spitfire Mk.IX Fuselage Correction
Loon Models' 1/48 scale Spitfire Mk.IX fuselage correction could not be much
simpler.
Two complete fuselage halves are supplied in cream coloured resin. The halves
are securely taped to cardboard to prevent the resin from warping in transit or
storage. The entire package is shipped in small stout boxes.
There are no fuselage casting blocks or attachment points. These must have
been cleaned up before packing. There is a little thin resin flash to clean up,
but the casting is generally excellent.
The resin replacement fuselage is broken down in a similar fashion to the
equivalent kit parts, except the empennage around the tail wheel is cast in
place. This area is a separate insert in the Hasegawa kit.
Even the moulded sidewall detail is present.
This set also supplies an accurately sized and shaped spinner, the
early-style horizontal stabilizers with non-kinked elevators; short carburettor
intake (cast onto a new lower cowl part); and the early style, wide covers for
the "C" wing cannon. These were designed to be used when two 20mm cannon were
installed in each wing, but were seen used with other combinations too.
Different style wheels might be required too. Check your references for
individual subjects.
So, is this an accurate conversion? I can state that it looks much
better than the Hasegawa fuselage, even using just the Mk.I eyeball.
Empirical data is a bit harder, as there seems to be a lot of detail and
dimensional variation in published scale drawings.
For example, Loon Models state that they have used the SAMI Spitfire
"Comprehensive Guide for the Modeller" as one of many references. As an
experiment, I compared the resin fuselage to the 1/48 scale drawing of the
Spitfire IXe in that book, and their lengths were identical. I compared the
resin fuselage with the 1/48 scale drawing immediately above this plan
(the Spitfire IXc); and the Loon part came up several millimteres short. And
these scale plans were on the same page of the same book!
Compared to my Hasegawa 1/48 scale Spitfire IXc kit fuselage, the Loon part
is approximately 3mm longer to the rudder hinge line. The position and size of
the canopy is identical, but the height of the rear fuselage and the taper of
the lower rear fuselage to the bottom of the rudder hinge line has been
improved. Also, panel lines have been rescribed in different positions to
reflect the overall increase in length of the rear fuselage. These new panel
lines are very slightly wider than those on the rest of the fuselage.
It is important to remember that this is not a simple "plug". It is, in
effect, a new rear fuselage. The fact that it it attached to the entire fuselage
makes the modeller's job much easier.
Instructions are supplied as a double-sided letter-sized sheet. The parts
really are simple replacements for kit items, so nothing more is really
required.
LO48209 - Spitfire Mk.VIII Fuselage Correction
The Spitfire Mk.VIII was a more standardised version that the stop-gap Mk.IX.
The early carby and wide blisters are therefore not included in this set.
The fuselage is set up for the retracting tail wheel with the cut out for the
rear gear doors.
Apart from that, the same comments apply to this set as for the Spitfire IX
fuselage correction.
Loon Models has tackled an ambitious project and delivered a very creditable
result.
There is no doubt that the Loon Models Spitfire fuselage corrections combined
with the new spinner will improve both the length and the proportions of the
Hasegawa kit. The correction set does not fix every detail, but the big problems
are addressed.
The simplicity of the sets is very welcome. Even relatively new modellers
should be able to handle this conversion.
If you are someone who has been delaying building Hasegawa's Spitfire Mk.IX
or VIII kits because of its dimensional woes, Loon Models' 1/48 scale Spitfire
fuselages will be the answer to your prayers!
Highly Recommended.
Thanks to Roll Models for the review samples
Loon Models accessories may be ordered from Roll Models:
http://www.rollmodels.com/
Review Copyright © 2003 by
Brett Green
Page Created 09 October, 2003
Last updated 09 October, 2003
Back to HyperScale
Main Page
|