F-4
Phantom II Accessories
Second Look
AirDOC,
1/48
Reviewed by David W. Aungst
HyperScale is proudly supported by
Squadron.com
Never say
that reviews do not work and are ignored by the
model manufactures. There have been a number of
cases where product reviews brought out major
issues in the products that in turn were fixed
by the manufacture. I have now found myself the
instigator of one such episode.
Back in November of 2004, I reviewed a series
of resin update sets from AirDOC. While
most of the sets were fine, I did have a few
issues and could not recommend a couple of the
sets. AirDOC contacted me shortly after
the reviews hit the Internet and conveyed their
disappointment that some of the sets were not as
good as I had hoped (and that the reviews did
not sound very positive). They informed me that
they would rework those sets and fix them.
This last week, I got the updated sets in the
mail for a re-review. There are three sets that
AirDOC has revised, as follows.
F-4 Phantom
Underwing Inboard Weapons Pylons (48003)
|
Set Pieces |
|
|
Instructions |
|
Find my original
review of this product on
this page.
This was one of
the sets I originally labeled as
Highly Recommended, but it had a
couple of nit-picky problems that have
been addressed.
- My first nit-picky point was
with the large pylon sway braces at
the top of the pylons where they
attach to the wing. These were not
provided in the original set and
still are missing, but they are now
mentioned in the instructions. Since
all the Hasegawa kits have
these braces (inappropriately)
molded to the lower side of the
wing, and molding the thin items in
resin was proving to be a problem,
AirDOC is choosing to still
leave these items out of the set. I
am OK with this.
- My other issue involved the
flare and chaff dispenser pieces
that attach to the rear portions of
the pylons. My original set had two
left side pieces and no right side
ones. I thought this might have been
a packing error on my specific set.
However, this was apparently an
oversight by AirDOC where
they had only created a left side
master. They have created the right
side master and now include it in
the set. The new item is seen in the
above image as the gray resin piece.
This sets is still
Highly
Recommended. I still
need a ton more of these sets.
|
|
F-4C/D
Conversions (48009)
|
Set Pieces |
|
|
Instructions |
|
|
Figure 1 |
|
|
Figure 2 |
|
AirDOC has
combined two sets into one here. This
used to be sets 48004 and 48005. Now,
this single set will accomplish either
of the conversions covered in the other
two sets. Find my original review of
these products on
this page.
The F-4C and F-4D
conversion sets were the two I could not
recommend in my earlier reviews. The
issues with the original sets rendered
them difficult (if not impossible) to
easily use. AirDOC has come a
long way to fix the issues.
- My first issue with the original
sets involved the lack of a correct
F-4C nose. There are three distinct
nose fairings found on the F-4C/D
Phantom, one for the F-4C and two
for the F-4D. The original sets only
provided the two F-4D styles,
missing the F-4C style fairing. The
new updated set now contains all
three nose fairing styles.
- My second issue with the
original sets involved very poor fit
of the nose cones to the kit
fuselage. A major step was created
all the way around the nose that was
going to be impossible to fix
without obliterating all the surface
detailing of the forward fuselage.
AirDOC fixed this issue by
not replacing the entire nose cone.
Instead, they only provide the chin
fairings as separate pieces. The
nose will now fit fine as you keep
the kit's nose cone, then you add on
the appropriate fairing. I much
prefer this approach.
The problem is that the fairings are
not all the same size in the set. As
can be seen in Figure 1 to
the right, the F-4C style fairing is
considerably smaller (not as long)
as the two F-4D fairings. I have
been unable to determine if this
difference is correct. I have
literally a two-foot-high stack of
F-4 Phantom books, not to mention
countless personal photos I have
taken over the years. In all that, I
can not get a conclusive answer to
the length of the chin fairings. My
gut feel, just looking at how the
fairings fit the kit's nose cone, is
that the F-4C fairing is pretty
close to correct, but the two F-4D
fairings are too long.
This is all easily fix-able with a
couple minutes of filing and sanding
on the F-4D fairings.
Figure 2 shows the F-4C
fairing attached to the Hasegawa
F-4J nose cone. All three of the
chin fairings fit the shape of the
F-4J nose cone really well. The thin
gap visible in the image is actually
already filled by the super glue I
used to attach the fairing. The
whole process of removing the
fairing from its slag, cleaning up
the part, and attaching it to the
already assembled nose cone took
under two minutes.
- Some additions to the set that
were not there before are the
horizontal tails. Having them in
this set removes the need to
purchase an additional set to
complete your F-4C/D conversion. You
will still need a new cockpit and
potentially new weapons pylons, but
the instructions now include this
information.
I am changing my evaluation of this
set to
Recommended. The issues
with the F-4D chin fairing sizes are
easily fixable with only a little
sanding.
Customer satisfaction is important to
AirDOC. To help correct the
already sold F-4C and F-4D conversions
sets that modelers already have in their
model stashes (update sets 48004 and
48005), I have received word from
AirDOC that they will replace the
nose cones of the original sets for
anyone that purchased them. Send the
nose cone pieces from the original sets
you purchased, along with $3.00 (US) to
cover postage, to the following address.
AirDOC
-- Verlag Andreas Klein
Wilhelmstr. 2b
D-91054 Erlangen
Germany |
They will send out
to you (via airmail) the updated pieces
of this new set to replace the incorrect
nose cones of the original sets. I think
this is a great deal, and it further
shows AirDOC's commitment to
getting the sets right and pleasing
their customers. |
|
Un-Slotted
Horizontal Tails (48010)
|
Set Pieces |
|
|
Instructions |
|
Find my original
review of this product on
this page.
This set's resin
content did not change. The only update
was the inclusion of an instruction
sheet. But, this is an important change
as it allows the set to be described
better.
The tails still do not include the
arrowhead reinforcing plates, but their
absence is described. Also, my earlier
review was incorrect in that the
arrowhead reinforcing plates did not get
applied to the F-4C/D aircraft until
well after the Vietnam conflict. Hence,
you can build any Vietnam-era F-4C/D
from these tails with no problems.
Adding the reinforcing plates to the
tails is described in the instructions,
but the provided templates seem somehow
out of proportion. Laying the resin
pieces onto the templates shows they are
not quite in proportion, but I feel they
are close enough to use for the purpose.
The template only shows the topside
reinforcing plates. The bottomside
plates are mostly the same, though.
As the instructions say, check your
references closely when adding the
reinforcing plates. Some aircraft only
had topside plates, others only had
bottomside plates, still others had both
top and bottomside plates. I have
personally seen most every mix of top
and bottom plates you can think of.
This sets is still
Recommended.
This set provides the best scaled
versions of the slot-less horizontal
tails. If you have need of tails without
the reinforcing plates, it is definitely
the best show going. If you need the
arrowhead reinforcing plates for the
specific aircraft you want to model,
adding them is not all that difficult.
The provided template will assist you in
the task. |
I am really pleased to see AirDOC fix
the issues in their earlier releases. I now need
to stock up on a few more F-4C/D conversion
sets.
|
|
|
Review Text and Images Copyright © 2005 by
David W. Aungst
Page Created 15 June, 2005
Last updated 15 June, 2005
Back to HyperScale Main Page
Back to Reviews Page
|